Celina Insurance Group Creates a Stand-out Agent Experience to Drive Agent Loyalty

Midwest mutual insurer scores near-perfect agent satisfaction with the launch of Glia

Listerhill logo
Challenge
Challenge
Solution
Solution
Challenge
digital-first service
Replace legacy chat solution for independent agents with expanded digital interaction capabilities
Solution
Glia Digital Customer Service empowers agents to leverage chat, OnScreen Voice, Video, Screen Sharing, and CoBrowsing with Celina team
Challenge
digital-first service
Provide a modern, tech-forward agent experience to attract and retain agent business
Solution
Enhanced agent relationships with Celina representatives through digital-first support
Challenge
digital-first service
Expand digital interactions for agents beyond underwriting team
Solution
Enable agents to seamlessly connect with underwriting, tech support, accounting services, and senior management

Results

Agent Satisfaction 4.93/5 - for all Glia Interactions

Agents say Celina’s digital support experience is superior to larger carriers

Fast and easy implementation defies expectations based on company size

Celina logo
assets icon
$189M in written premium
branches icon
Writes business in 5 states
branches icon
Serves ~ 400 independent insurance agencies with about 3,500 users

Evolving from Basic Chat to Full Digital Customer Service

Compared to other marquee names in the Property & Casualty insurance space, Celina Insurance Group is smaller in size, but they make a big impression on their network of independent agencies with a modern, tech-forward agent experience.

Celina Insurance Group, operating since 1914, has built their business around relationships with independent agencies. The Midwest mutual insurer serves agencies across five states—Ohio, Indiana, Tennessee, West Virginia, and Kentucky—with the promise that whenever agents reach out, Celina always answers.

The Celina website has a page dedicated to their agent experience: “When you call, we always answer. When you work with us, we don’t just know your name. We know your business needs, your goals and your story.” Agents report that this experience is what brings them back, time and again.

Celina has always relied on a stand-out agent experience to help retain agents who might otherwise default to working with the more recognizable names. They create that experience with the best tech available.

Moving Beyond Basic Chat to Better Messaging and Transcript History

Early on, Celina adopted chat, rolling out the digital channel on their agent portal in 2003 through a solution from IBM. The mutual insurer enabled their agents to view Celina’s underwriting team and begin a chat interaction with any of them. While agents loved the ability to chat, there were features missing from what Celina aspired to offer.

First, there was no way for the agent to know if the underwriter had seen the chat and would respond—in contrast to Glia, where the Celina team has 30 seconds to accept the interaction. Agents no longer worry about a message lost in the void or feel left in the dark.

Second, agents often would request a transcript or chat history, but the previous solution didn’t enable that. Celina wanted a solution that would give agents every tool they needed to streamline workflows and bring clarity with easy documentation.

But Celina knew that new technology innovation would let them take that even further, going beyond chat for their agent offerings.

More Sophisticated Interactions with Video, Screen Sharing, and File Sharing

Rob Shoenfelt, SVP - Chief Information and Innovation Officer, wanted the ability for agents to interact with the Celina team in any digital channel—chat, voice, video—with additional capabilities like screen sharing, CoBrowsing, and file-sharing to create an all-in-one experience.

“It really matters to agents because it makes us easy to work with. They could place a policy with anyone, but they come to Celina because we make it simple for them to do business with us,” Shoenfelt said. “They tell us this is a great solution."

Chat is well-suited for many interactions, but more complex conversations around risk are better suited for voice or video. In particular, video was an important differentiator for Celina. One of the major outcomes of the pandemic internally at Celina was leveraging video for meetings that would otherwise take place in-office. While nothing can replace in-person interactions, video enables a more personal interaction than an email, chat, or even phone call ever could.

When Celina saw Glia’s Digital Customer Service solution, they knew it would enable them to provide the holistic digital experience they’d been looking to provide to their agents. Less than a year after first meeting the Glia team, Celina had launched the solution for their independent agents.

Building Better Relationships with Independent Agents

For carriers like Celina that are reliant upon independent agents to bring in business, it’s all about creating an experience and a relationship that entices agents to pick them over the other carriers they’re appointed with.

Outside of price, the people at Celina and the technology they provide agents are the key factors that determine if an agent wants to place their business with them. Shoenfelt said the agent doesn’t care how big Celina is, they care if someone is going to be on the other end of the computer or phone when they need help.

“Why do agents write business with Celina when they could write with one of the big companies?” asked Shoenfelt. “They put it with Celina because of the relationships. It’s the only reason. Do we have the lowest price? Sometimes. A lot of times we don't, but they still put the business with us because it's a relationship and they know that if they reach out, they can get help. The Glia solution enables that, and it builds that relationship.”

The Celina team is always there — and with Glia, the technology is too.

Improving Agent Satisfaction While Operating More Efficiently

On top of the benefits Celina has seen in improving their relationships with agents, the mutual insurer has realized efficiency gains as well. One of the key improvements over Celina’s previous chat solution is the ability for the Celina rep to immediately have information on the agent they’re speaking with. This auto-authentication accelerates Celina’s ability to assist the agent with their needs.

With Glia’s CoView technology, the Celina team is also presented with immediate visual context of where the agent is on Celina’s system. This functionality has enabled Celina to more efficiently and effectively resolve agent inquiries.

Celina has also seen improvements in agent satisfaction and efficiency by enabling the agent to select who they need to speak with, cutting out the need to transfer to another underwriter or someone in accounting. Leveraging business logic behind the scenes, an agent is presented with their core Celina support team who knows their business once they’re logged into Celina’s system.

These enhancements with Glia are driving more efficient and personalized interactions between independent agents that represent Celina and the Celina team. For the thousands of interactions that have flowed through Glia in the first six months since implementation, agents have responded with a 4.93/5 satisfaction rating.

The Glia solution enables Celina to meet their agents in whatever channel they prefer. Some agents still email or call, but for those that have adopted the digital channels, Shoenfelt said they rarely opt to communicate another way.

“There's a large segment of agents who want to communicate this way,” Shoenfelt said. “Now we can meet them there. Even better, we can meet them well beyond their expectation, way beyond what they thought was even possible. And they love it.”

Reinvent How You Serve Your Members

Request a Demo

“With Glia we increased our conversion by over 200%”

Director of Digital - Top 10 Bank

More Success Stories

Catalyst Award Winner
White Paper Transitioning with Technology for Fiduciary Responsibility
OvalDownload icon

From Legacy to Leading-Edge: Azura CU's Rapid Digital Transformation

Wait times and abandon rates plummet within 30 days of launching Glia
New
White Paper Transitioning with Technology for Fiduciary Responsibility
OvalDownload icon

Unitus Community Credit Union: Reaching a New Community

Mission-Driven Innovation for Financial Inclusion
New
White Paper Transitioning with Technology for Fiduciary Responsibility
OvalDownload icon

ICCU Drives Member Growth & Community Education with AI

Glia Virtual Assistant & Digital Customer Service helps CU attract, educate younger members
VIEW ALL SUCCESS STORIES >